Motif XF, Why?
- October 11th, 2010
- Write comment
I was thumbing through the October issue of Keyboard magazine and found a review of the Yamaha Motif X8. When I first started making electronic music back in the 90s I bought an Ensoniq SQ-1 and then an EPS-16 Plus. I had to. There was no other way to make electronic music back in those days. I needed a digital synth, and a sampler. The other options, at the time, were workstations like the Korg M1 and the Yamaha SY-77. I had a very early version of Cubase that I used to sequence, but I also sequenced using the onboard sequencer of my hardware synths because I didn’t want to take my computer with me when I played live. It was either that, or put tracks on a DAT tape (which I also did).
But the worst part was: I paid out the ass for those pieces of hardware. The cheapest thing I had was Cubase! I know I paid $1,300 for the SQ-1, and I can’t recall how much I paid for the sampler–but it was a LOT. I even upgraded my system with a Yamaha SY-85 and a Emu ESI-4000 (I actually still have both of these).
But that was years ago. Today, I have a complete studio on my laptop. I could add up all of my soft synths, Ableton Live, Pro-Tools, and my interface and microphone and it wouldn’t even come close to how much I spent in 1990 for two pieces of hardware.
So now I see this Yamaha Motif for $3k, and I have to ask: Why? Why would I drop that kind of money on one piece of gear? For $3k I could get a new, maxed-out Apple G5 iMac, then load it up with all the software I’d ever need (effects, plug-ins, analog synth replicas). Why on Earth would I give Yamaha $3k of my money? You have a giant piece of gear you have to lug around, and if you ever have issues with it you have to take it into the shop for repair (or it may just up and die like my SQ-1). With my computer, I just reload the software onto another machine. And I keep backups of all my songs and digital audio on an external hard drive. Plus I can record guitar and vocals into my laptop, and put everything together for mixing and mastering (can’t do that with a synth).

To be honest, I thought the hardware synth thing would be gone by now. I thought Yamaha and company would put out piano controllers and things like that, but I figured they’d stop production of synths and focus on software. As far as I know, only Korg has delved into that with the Legacy series (which is a memory hog and a dud in my book).
I just wonder. I wonder who is buying the hard gear? I haven’t even set foot in a music store in over a year. I buy everything at musiciansfriend.com or audiomidi.com. I always hated the annoying salespeople at Guitar Center and Brook Mays. They were pushy, and usually stuck-up musicians themselves.
Well, obviously someone is buying these things. I just don’t know why someone would. My SY-85 makes a good doorstop.


I realized today that I need more posts about music. I have so many interests, it’s hard to squeeze them all in here. Well one of my favorite albums was given to me by a friend, and I went completely crazy over it. It’s Darondo’s 
